Defamation
What counts as defamation, who is liable for it, and what happens when a collection lawyer defames a Mizrahi Tefahot Bank customer in front of a bank representative.
The legal framework
The Prohibition of Defamation Law, 5725-1965, defines defamation as material whose publication is liable to degrade a person in the eyes of others, to make them an object of contempt for acts or traits attributed to them, or to damage their office, business or profession. Attributing theft, fraud or criminality to a person sits at the core of that definition.
Publication is a condition, not a technicality. Under section 2, a statement becomes a publication when it reaches a person other than the subject. The same words spoken in private are not a publication; spoken in the presence of a third party, such as a representative of the creditor bank, they are. That distinction decides whether a cause of action arises at all.
The law provides three central defences. Truth in publication, conditional on the publication having been of public interest. Permitted publications, which cover, among others, statements made in the course of judicial proceedings. And the defence of good faith, conditional on the publication having been made in circumstances the law recognises and on the publisher not having exceeded what was reasonable in them.
Section 7A allows compensation to be awarded without the injured party proving loss, and doubles the sum where the publication was made with intent to harm. The reasoning is plain: damage to reputation is not measured in receipts.
A collection context is not a defence in itself. A lawyer representing a creditor acts within a binding professional framework, and the Bar Association's rules of ethics require conduct befitting the profession towards the opposing party as well, and certainly in the presence of his own client.