The bank's fiduciary duty
Contract law, the duty of good faith, the duties of care and disclosure, and the Bank of Israel's Proper Conduct of Banking Business directives. What the law requires of a banking corporation, and where those requirements were not met.
The legal framework
The relationship between a bank and its customer is not an ordinary commercial one. The bank holds information, systems and capacity to act that the customer does not, and Israeli case law has derived from this heightened duties of trust and disclosure, going beyond what is asked of an ordinary contracting party.
The starting point is contract law. Section 12 of the Contracts Law (General Part), 5733-1973, requires negotiating in good faith and in a customary manner, and section 39 applies the same duty to performing a contract and to exercising a right arising from it. The practical meaning: even a legitimate contractual right can be exercised in bad faith, and exercising it that way is a breach.
To this is added the Banking Law (Customer Service), 5741-1981, which forbids a banking corporation from misleading a customer on a material matter and sets out disclosure duties regarding the service and its terms. Alongside the legislation stand the Proper Conduct of Banking Business directives of the Supervisor of Banks at the Bank of Israel, which bind banking corporations to rules of conduct towards their customers.
In practical terms the translation is simple. A customer who asks how much he owes is entitled to an accurate balance. A customer who asks to repay a loan early is entitled to have the request examined and answered. A customer who asks for approval to sell a pledged vehicle and clear the debt from the proceeds is entitled to a substantive answer, in writing, within a reasonable time.
When no such answer is given, the debt does not stand still. Interest, costs and legal fees are added to it. The question of who created that growth is not a technical question but a legal one, and it is examined here against the documents and the dates.
Articles in this section
Mizrahi Bank, 1936: "In the name of the Führer and Reich Chancellor". Hermann Struck's Cross of Honour
Published: 14 November 2026In 1936 the German consulate in Jerusalem awarded Hermann Struck, a founder of Mizrahi Bank, the Cross of Honour for front-line fighters. In the same archive: a 1917 letter to his mother about his appointment, the school rules of Ober Ost, and a 1963 letter to his widow.
The bank's fiduciary dutyMizrahi Bank, 1916: the founder, the prisoner-of-war camps and the race research
Published: 13 November 2026The anthropologist Felix von Luschan commissioned Hermann Struck, later a founder of Bank Mizrahi, to draw prisoners of war in the German camps, to record their "racial features". 48 of the sheets were examined: signatures in Arabic, and beside them tribe, age and trade.
The bank's fiduciary dutyHermann Struck: from the German military government Ober Ost to the Mizrahi Bank share
Published: 12 November 2026A 1924 Mizrahi Bank share is signed by Hermann Struck as a director. In 1916 to 1918 he was a censor and head of the Jewish affairs department in the German military government Ober Ost, and was authorised to recruit Jewish workers.
The bank's fiduciary dutyMizrahi Bank, 1916: "All Our Roads Lead to Germany". Hermann Struck's Book Reviewed
11 November 2026A critical review of the 1916 book by Hermann Struck, later a founder of Bank Mizrahi (today Mizrahi Tefahot), and Herbert Eulenberg: the Ludendorff dedication, "spiritual conquest", "the subjugated" and the Jews. Full book PDF.
The bank's fiduciary dutyAn application to increase a debt at the Israeli Execution Office: five checks before the registrar approves
Published: 11 November 2026What Form 502 is, which attachments the application must include, and how to check the number of days, the interest start date and the arithmetic itself. With an example from a Mizrahi Tefahot Leasing pledge file.
The bank's fiduciary dutyComplaints against Bank Mizrahi Tefahot: about 28% upheld in 2023, and the bank links the rise to the Igud merger
Published: 11 November 2026Mizrahi Tefahot's 2023 report: about 28% of complaints upheld, with the rise linked to Igud customers whose account transfer was not completed. 615 merger complaints in 2022, 540 in 2023, and no mention in 2024.
The bank's fiduciary dutyMizrahi Tefahot Leasing: 100 shekels a day on a pledged car, and interest counted from the decision date
Published: 11 November 2026A NIS 100 daily charge on a car not handed to the receiver, two debt increases totalling NIS 23,612.23, interest counted from 13.1.2026, and an unexplained NIS 167.40 in a Chen Fisher Gabbay sheet.
The bank's fiduciary dutyMizrahi Tefahot Bank: the Ludendorff dedication, the shares sold to European Jews, and "no claimants"
Published: 10 November 2026In 1916 a founder of Bank Mizrahi dedicated a book to General Ludendorff. In 1924 the bank's shares were sold to Mizrachi members from Germany, Poland and Belgium with a promise. In 1939 the bank wrote "no claimants" next to their deposits.
The bank's fiduciary dutyMizrahi Tefahot Bank fined NIS 6.8 million under Israel’s anti-money laundering and terror financing law
Published: 9 November 2026On 25 March 2026 the Bank of Israel sanctions committee fined Mizrahi Tefahot Bank NIS 6.8 million: transfers from abroad not screened against the designation list, 12 unusual transactions not reported, 37 know-your-customer failures. A similar request filed the same day against Bank Leumi ended in a NIS 2.1 million fine.
The bank's fiduciary dutyMizrahi Tefahot Bank and the dormant accounts: no interest, fees charged, then closed
Published: 9 November 2026According to the Knesset inquiry report, Bank Mizrahi "apparently did not pay interest on accounts without activity, and on the other hand charged them fees". Credit balances eroded, turned into debit balances and were closed by the branch.
The bank's fiduciary dutyUnion Bank (Agud) to Mizrahi Tefahot: 615 Complaints and "Ad Hoc" Fixes
Published: 8 November 2026615 complaints about the Agud merger in 2022 and 540 in 2023. Bank Agud’s final report: "faults that occurred were handled ad hoc", corporate customers converted "in a non-automated manner". What to ask the bank and how to complain.
The bank's fiduciary dutyMizrahi Bank and the 1939 deposits: "they should not be taken into account"
Published: 8 November 2026"They should not be taken into account", the bank wrote in 1939 about deposits of depositors in Poland. In 1940 it reported "accounts whose owners died" to the Supervisor of Banks. In 2001 the auditors were told the bank had no material.
The bank's fiduciary dutyBank Mizrahi and the Haavara Agreement: money from Germany and deposits "that will not be claimed"
Published: 7 November 2026Records of the Knesset Commission of Inquiry document money transferred from Nazi Germany straight to Bank HaMizrahi, and letters in which management marked the deposits of European Jews as "will not be claimed". What that says about a bank's duty of trust to its depositors.
The bank's fiduciary dutyBank Mizrahi was convicted of a crime
Published: 4 November 2026In 1994 United Mizrahi Bank, today Mizrahi Tefahot Bank, was convicted of obtaining something by deceit in aggravated circumstances over false advice to customers. It did not appeal. Its CEO was convicted of fraud and false entries in the financial statements.
The bank's fiduciary dutyComplaining to Israel's Banking Supervisor about Mizrahi Tefahot
Published: 2 November 2026Two stages: the public complaints commissioner at Bank Mizrahi Tefahot, and after 45 days the Banking Supervision at the Bank of Israel. What to attach, how to word it, and what to do when the bank does not answer.
The bank's fiduciary dutyIgud Leasing: what happened after the Mizrahi Tefahot merger
Published: 2 November 2026Igud Leasing is now Mizrahi Tefahot Leasing. When the name and owner changed, what it means for a car loan customer, and what to check in the contract.
The bank's fiduciary dutyMizrahi-Tefahot and the US Justice Department: a $195 million deal
Published: 1 November 2026Back-to-back loans in Los Angeles, code names, shell companies on islands and mail kept in drawers in Israel and Switzerland: what the bank admitted to the US Justice Department, and how much it paid.
The bank's fiduciary dutyThe bank lost the documents? When does that usually happen?
Published: 1 November 2026"No material at all", management told the auditors. Then ledgers and minutes turned up. Three moments when bank records disappear, according to the Knesset inquiry's audit report, and the 2012 settlement.
The bank's fiduciary dutyEarly repayment at Mizrahi Tefahot: what happens when a borrower asks to pay off the loan and nobody answers?
Published: October 16, 2026Mortgage borrowers argued with the banks over the price of early repayment. A Mizrahi Tefahot Leasing customer asked in writing to pay off his car loan, and instead of a payoff amount he got three proceedings.
Read ↗ The bank's fiduciary dutyFalse reports by Mizrahi Tefahot Bank
Published: 5 October 2026Two personal services while the vehicle owner was abroad, an affidavit by an "employee of the creditor" who turned out to work for the bank, "delivered" and also "affixed" in the same affidavit, and a cancelled legal fee that came back into the ledger. And why the size of the debt matters.
Read ↗ The bank's fiduciary dutyHe asked to defer a payment in wartime, and found himself barred from leaving the country
Published: 4 October 2026The request to defer the payments, the "delayed" entry in the bank's log, the payment collected that same day, the warning sent to an address with no street name, and the two files opened while the vehicle owner was abroad.
Read ↗